Phở Bò (Vietnamese Beef Pho Noodle Soup) is the national dish of Vietnam, a dish that many Vietnamese hold dear to their heart. Learn the authentic way to make beef pho and serve it like a true Vietnamese, as well as cooking tips you may not find elsewhere.
The beef pho broth recipe in this post leans toward Northern-style (since we’re from Hanoi) with suggestions to tweak it to be more like Southern-style. You will also find instructions to serve the noodle soup in each style.
What is Phở Bò
“Phở” means rice noodles and “bò” means beef. A bowl of beef phở consists of soft slippery noodles in a hearty, beefy yet fragrant broth and beef slices of your choice. This dish is the most famous Vietnamese noodle soup without any doubts.
Some say pho bo originated in Hanoi while some firmly believe its origin was Nam Dinh, another Northern Vietnamese city a couple of hours away from the capital. Regardless, the dish was created in the North of Vietnam and traveled down South later.
In Vietnam, pho bo is well-loved as a breakfast. A lot of people also eat it as a quick lunch or late night supper. I’d say it’s delicious any time of the day.
Watch How to Cook Beef Pho at Home
Types of Beef Pho Noodle Soup
When talking about types of beef pho soup, we usually think of two ways of classification, by type of beef toppings and by region.
By Type of Beef Toppings
Whenever you go to a pho joint in Vietnam, you will be presented with various meat topping options, and each option has its specific name. Some popular ones are:
- Phở chín: beef noodle soup with well-done tender meat that can be brisket, flank or shank for example. It can also be called phở nạm. In English, it may be called well-done beef pho, beef brisket pho or beef flank pho.
- Phở tái: beef noodle soup with thin slices of raw meat quickly poached in the broth. The English translation for it is rare beef pho.
- Phở tái lăn: beef noodle soup with seared thin slices of beef which are very aromatic.
- Phở bò sốt vang: beef stew pho noodle soup, which has a different taste than those above but very hearty and flavorful. You can find my beef stew pho recipe here.
And of course, diners can combine meat toppings for their bowl of pho however they want. Besides the options above, they can also add beef meatballs (mostly in the South), tendons or tripes. Below is a photo of phở tái chín (or phở tái nạm), consisting of both well-done and rare beef.
Besides being the national dish, pho bo is also a topic of interest in Vietnamese literature from a long time ago. Two famous Vietnamese writers, Thạch Lam (1910-1942) and Nguyễn Tuân (1910-1987), both praised that the most traditional and tastiest pho noodle soup is the version with well-done beef. It also happens to be my most favorite type of pho soup, but it’s really a matter of personal preference. My dad, for example, prefers rare beef pho.
Now here’s the bigger debate of what is more delicious, Northern pho or Southern pho? As I have explained in many of my posts before, Northern and Southern cuisines have similarities while being very different. In general, someone born in the North will vouch for Northern pho and can rarely get used to Southern pho flavors and vice versa.
Again, it’s a matter of preference and here are some major differences.
- Northern pho: savory broth with very mild sweetness. The broth is clear with a golden hue. Pho is never served with hoisin sauce nor a veggie platter like in the South. The rice noodles are usually wider and each bowl often has a lot of scallion.
- Southern pho: sweet broth with a darker color. Pho is served with hoisin sauce and a veggie platter of bean sprouts, Thai basil and saw-tooth leaves. The rice noodles are not as wide, and there isn’t as much scallion in each bowl as with Northern pho.
What do we prefer? Our favorite will always be pho bo Hanoi.
Why This Recipe
This beef pho recipe is authentic with all real, natural ingredients. It is the result of a number of experiments and discussions between us, native Vietnameses who grew up eating pho on a daily basis for over 20 years of our life in the North, and our Saigonese chef friend. The authentic flavors are deeply engrained in us, and this recipe contains tips and secrets you may not find anywhere else.
We also spent a few years living in the US, so we had tried pho in different parts of the US. I think it is not difficult to cook pho at home, and this recipe is very straightforward. It just requires a bit of patience, and the result is better than what you will get at most restaurants.
Master Beef Pho Broth
The hearty and complexed broth of pho noodle soup is the result of slowly and gently simmering beef bones, meat, aromatics, and spices.
Beef Bones and Meat
I recommend using marrow bones for a deep flavor. Oxtail is an option and we used it in the past. The thing is oxtails don’t contain many bones, so the broth lacks depth even though it is beefy and that’s why you should still add some beef bones. Some other options are knuckle bones and neck bones.
Even when using bones, I think it’s still necessary to add a large boneless cut of beef like brisket and shank to the broth. They will make the broth more beefy and hearty. In addition, you can use them as well-done meat toppings for your pho bowls since they have a combination of meat and fat/muscle, resulting in a nice texture. Use kitchen twine to tie the meat before cooking to retain a nice shape.
Charred onions and ginger add another layer of depth to the broth. If you have shallots on hand, also char and add them for more complexity. You can char aromatics with a grill pan like I do in the video, or broil in the oven. It can take 10-15 minutes to do this, so be patient.
Beef pho spice blend consists of cassia bark/cinnamon (quế), star anise (đại hồi/hoa hồi), black cardamom pod (thảo quả), clove (đinh hương), coriander seed (hạt ngò), and fennel seed (tiểu hồi). Toast them in a skillet for several minutes until fragrant and place them in a spice bag for easy removal. In my opinion, the must-have spices are cinnamon, star anise, clove, and black cardamom pod.
Other ingredients you will need to flavor the broth are salt, fish sauce, and rock sugar. As a Northerner Vietnamese, I still think beef pho needs a small amount of rock sugar to round out the flavors. Chicken pho broth doesn’t need sugar though.
My pho broth recipe leans toward Northern-style, but generally you can tweak the amount of fish sauce and rock sugar to make it more like Southern-style if you want.
The Do’s and Don’ts that Make a Big Difference
Making pho at home isn’t rocket science. It is actually intuitive and straightforward, but there are quite a bit of small details that make a difference. Therefore, please follow the recipe as closely as you can. Here are some important tips to keep in mind:
- Do simmer gently and slowly with a lid slightly askew for a clear and complexed broth. I recommend simmering beef bones for at least 6 hours. Do 8 hours or more if you can since we notice a difference increasing to 8 hours.
- Don’t simmer the onions in the broth for too long or they will get slimy. 2 hours towards the end of cooking should be enough.
- Don’t add the spices right at the beginning. After 6-8 hours, your house will be filled with fragrances but not much is retained in the broth. Besides, simmering spices for an unnecessary long time will bring out its bitterness. So, add the spices in the last 1.5 – 2 hours of cooking.
- Do skim off excess fat but don’t discard all of it. We need some fat in the broth since some compounds that make our food flavorful are fat-soluble. It also gives you richness and a smooth mouthfeel.
- Don’t add fish sauce while simmering because the broth will turn sour. Wait until right before serving to season the broth with fish sauce and rock sugar.
- Personally, I’m not a fan of using MSG. If you like to use it, don’t add it while simmering. Add a small amount of it to your serving bowl right before pouring the hot broth.
- Whether you prefer well-done, rare or seared beef, slice it thinly against the grain.
How to Serve and Eat Beef Pho like in Vietnam
So far, we haven’t talked about pho, the rice noodles itself. You will want to use flat and fairly wide rice noodles. In Vietnam, people often use fresh rice noodles. You can use dried rice noodles which are more common outside of Vietnam.
Beef pho is served with different condiments in the North and the South of Vietnam. I will list what is often served in each region and you can pick and choose what you prefer.
Serving beef pho in Northern-style with the following accompaniments:
- paper-thin slices of onion
- shredded white scallion part and a lot of thinly sliced green scallion part and cilantro
- fried dough stick (quẩy): cut into short section and dip them in the broth. Personally, a pho experience is incomplete without these. I have a homemade fried dough sticks recipe here
- poached egg: poach an egg in a separate pot and serve in a separate bowl with pho broth or directly in your pho bowl. Don’t break the egg and eat it in one slurp if you can
- garlic slices in vinegar: balance the heartiness of the noodle soup. Honestly I’m not a fan of it, but it is a traditional accompaniment
- lime wedges and bird’s eye chili
Serving beef pho in Southern-style with the following accompaniments:
- thinly sliced scallions and cilantro
- hoisin sauce and sriracha
- a veggie platter with bean sprouts, Thai basil and saw-tooth leaves
- lime wedges and bird’s eye chili
I know there are a ton of pho recipes on the internet, but sadly many are not authentic or the cooking steps aren’t accurate. Also, there aren’t many recipes for Northern-style pho. I hope you will try my version and love it as much as we do. It is the flavor we grew up with in Hanoi, but of course you can tweak it to your liking. Please find detailed list of ingredients and instructions in the recipe card right below.
More pho recipes to try:
I’d love to hear what you think about the dish, so please feel free to leave a comment and a rating if you have tried it. New recipes are added every week so let’s connect on Facebook, Youtube, Pinterest and Instagram for the latest updates. You can find my collection of Vietnamese recipes here.
Authentic Vietnamese Beef Pho (Phở Bò)
For the Broth
- 3 lbs beef bones
- 1.25 lbs beef brisket
- 1 lb beef shank
- 14½ cups water (about 3.75 quarts)
- 1 tablespoon salt (and more for seasoning)
For the Spice Blend
- 1 large piece of cassia bark or 2-3 cinnamon sticks (about 0.2-0.25 oz)
- 6 star anises
- 6-7 cloves
- 1 tablespoon coriander seeds
- 2 teaspoons fennel seeds
- 1½-2 black cardamom pods, crushed open
For the Aromatics
- 2 medium yellow onions, skin-on, slice in half (about 12 oz)
- 2 big thumb-sized pieces of ginger, slice in half lengthwise plus 2 more slices (about 2.5 oz)
- 4-5 shallots
- 1 tablespoon fish sauce (to taste)
- 1 tablespoon rock sugar
For the Bowls
- 1.5-2 lbs cooked rice noodles
- thinly sliced steak, such as tenderloin or sirloin (optional, if you want to have rare beef pho)
- 1 medium yellow onion, thinly sliced into half moons (try to make them paper-thin)
- white scallion part, shredded
- green scallion part, thinly sliced
- cilantro, thinly sliced
- freshly-cracked black pepper
Prepare the Broth
- Par-boil beef bones in plenty of boiling water for 10 minutes then transfer to a bowl of cold water and clean the bones. Bring a stock pot with 3.75 quarts of water to a simmer, then add the bones together with 1 tablespoon of salt and 2 slices of ginger (about 2-inch long).
- Let everything come to a boil and skim off any foams, then reduce to a simmer. Cover with the lid askew and simmer very gently for 6-8 hours.
- While simmering the bones, use kitchen twine to tie the beef brisket and shank. Par-boil them in boiling water for a couple of minutes. Rinse and add them to the stock pot. Adjust the heat to maintain a gentle simmer and skim off foams. Cover with the lid askew.
- Cook the beef brisket and shank until tender to your liking. Beef brisket may take 2.5-3 hours and beef shank may take 1-1.5 hours. Once they are ready, remove them from the broth and add them to a bowl of iced water. Once cool, refrigerate them if the broth isn't ready yet.
- About 2.5 hours before finishing simmering the broth, char onions, ginger and shallots (all with skin-on) on a grill pan or broil in the oven. It may take 10-15 minutes and you will see charred marks on their skin. The onions will feel softer with some juices bubbling. Peel off the skin and blackened part from the charred onions, ginger and shallots.
- In a skillet over medium-low to medium heat, toast the spices for 2-3 minutes until fragrant. Be careful to avoid burning them (especially the cloves). Add them to a spice bag.
- Skim off excess fat from the broth (note: leave some fat in the broth). Place the spice bag, onion, ginger and shallot in the stock pot and simmer them in the broth for about 2 hours prior to serving, then remove them.
- Right before serving, season the broth with additional salt (I often add another teaspoon of salt), fish sauce and rock sugar to taste. Also check to see if too much water evaporates and you can add a splash of water to the broth if needed. Each bowl needs about 1½-2 cups (360-480ml) of broth depending on size (medium or large).
Assemble Beef Pho Bowls
- Slice beef brisket and shank thinly against the grain.
- Place rice noodles in serving bowls. Top with sliced cooked beef, raw beef slices (optional), thinly sliced onions, thinly sliced scallions, cilantro and freshly cracked black pepper.
- Bring the broth back to a boil. Add the white parts of scallions to the broth to poach for several seconds, and then immediately ladle the soup into pho bowls. Serve right away with accompaniments of your choice. See list of accompaniments in the Notes below.
- Stop when there are about 2.5 hours of simmering required for the bones (after Step 4 in the Prepare the Broth section). Refrigerate the broth. The next day, skim off excess fat that has solidified (note: leave some fat in the broth) and continue cooking from Step 5.
- Stop after Step 7 in the Prepare the Broth section. Refrigerate the broth. The next day, heat the broth on the stove with a small piece of ginger and a small amount of spice (like a small piece of cinnamon, a star anise and a clove) for 20-30 minutes if you feel the spice fragrance is not as potent as the previous day.
Have you tried using those instant pot to cook the broth? I’m thinking it will be quicker.
Not sure how to convert the timing of it.
I used my pressure cooker to cook the broth before, but it’s not an Instant Pot brand so you may need to tweak the time as needed. I blanched all the bones and then pressure cooked for about 1.5 hours. The meat like beef shank took about 30 minutes. Then I transferred the broth and bones to a stockpot and simmered on the stove with all the ginger, onion and spices for another hour. Last step was adding seasonings to taste. I hope this helps and please let me know how things turn out with the Instant Pot 🙂.
This recipe came out pretty good! I didn’t have all the ingredients but even with me improvising it came out very well, especially the consistency and complexity. Like another user mentioned mines came out a bit bland because I over diluted the stock. I was able to bring back some of its charm by throwing back in those meats, that were refrigerated to a simmer a bit longer(cleaned the foam and some fats of the top again). I also add some charm by making my own hoisin sauce replica(I had zero) with the help of soy sauce, honey and a bit of brown sugar. That gave me a nice pop of flavor, along with a dash of rice vinegar. Overall I was satisfied with this dish and it’s instructions. Next time I will be sure to add more bones and meat for flavor to avoid the extra steps. This dish took me 12 hours, but that’s only because I wasn’t sure I had enough bones and meat to give the impact I want, so I let it go longer.
Hi, I’m trying to make this for a party of 5 people.
Is 3.75 quarts of water enough for 6 servings?
I tried another pho recipe before and it used 6 quarts of water and only boiled for 3 hours so just wanted to make sure I will have enough broth to serve my guests T_T
It should be enough for 5-6 people, but if you have big eaters, it may be safer to use a bit more bones and liquid for some extra broth. The water wouldn’t evaporate too much since we simmer gently, but you can always add some back near the end. Please let me know how it turns out.
Maybe it’s the cook but this recipe didn’t turn out the way I’d wanted. I followed the directions in its entirety. I parboiled the meat. I used bone marrow and neck bones. I simmered it for the 8 hours. I had all of the spices and cooked in the pan until it was fragrant. Then threw it in the pot along with the charred onion and ginger after 6 hours of simmering. Idk what I did wrong but it’s bland and I feel like it’s missing something.
I’m sorry to hear that it didn’t turn out the way you want. I received quite a lot of positive feedbacks for the recipe through comments here and on Pinterest, but I’m happy to look into what might have been missing in your case. You said you used bone marrow (or marrow bones?) and neck bones. Did you also add a large boneless cut of beef? Without that, the broth may not be hearty or beefy enough. You can also season the broth to taste with more salt and rock sugar if needed.
If you are here to see if this is good and worth it, it absolutely is, YOU NEED TO MAKE THIS!
I just wanted to say how amazing this all came out and this is definitely not the first time I have made pho. We play around with different spices and cuts all the time, change the simmering and such. Even had a few people suggest some prepared season packets, and I won’t knock them because they were good. However, after eating pho my entire 30 years of life, cooking my own for 8 years, this is by far a top favourite.
My friend never had pho so she couldn’t compare it, but she eats very farm western style foods so I was a little nervous to have her try it. Proud to say I converted another person into a pho lover! All with your recipe, which I will be making from now on.
The soup has a lot of flavour, the meat was actually nice and tender ( I prefer the shank or any meat off the bone ) and the tips to add the seasoning at the end blew my mind. I think that is why I always end up losing flavour and compensate by making double the spice for my pho.
Thank you for you the recipe and putting a lot of effort into explaining the details between the different styles of south and north pho. I enjoyed the read and I realized I do prefer the north more for sure (probably biased though XD )
Off to make this for the fam jam now!
Thank you for the feedback and I’m sorry I missed your comment. I’m glad it came out great for you. It’s also wonderful to hear that you enjoyed the read. It brings me joy to be able to share what I learned through my experiments and discussions with my chef friend here, and know that some may find it useful :). I hope you will continue to convert more friends into pho lovers.
Great instructions but unfortunately I’ll keep spending the $15 a bowl because through all this work and buying up the ingredients for one person is crazy.
I do make a faux-pho that tastes good (not great) and is affordable but I wish they came up with a quick for one pho recipe!
Yeah I agree making pho requires some work. Good thing is most of the cooking time is about letting the soup simmer away. Maybe when you have time, you can make a large batch, then divvy it up and freeze all the extra portions. To shorten the time, I sometimes pressure cook the bones for 60-90 minutes and then simmer on the stove for just a little more.
What a beautiful pho bo recipe, thank you so much for sharing. I only boiled for 6 hours but still so tasty, next time I’ll do the full 8!
Also I tasted it before I put the rock sugar and gosh sauce in and was so worried about the flavour but once those 2 ingredients went in it was perfect!
This Vietnamese Beef Pho recipe is so good! It’s so delicious and flavorful! Adding a Pho Noodle – Annie Chun’s Pad Thai Rice Noodles from Karman Foods makes it more delicious. My new fave dish!
Hi Sophie, I’ve been browsing your recipes and keep bookmarking one after another. I made your Cha Ca La Vong recipe with a bit less shrimp paste and thought it was excellent. I plan to try your Pho Bo recipe as soon as I can find the different cuts of beef.
I’m very excited to find a Hanoi/Northern Vietnamese cuisine recipe site! Both my parents were born in the north. They moved to the south in the 60s, and then the US in ’75. My mom learned to cook from her Grandmother & Mother, who were both from Hanoi, and she has retained a Northern palate. My dad has retained a Northern palate as well. I grew up almost exclusively eating my mom’s mostly Vietnamese homemade food (she would cook a variety other cuisines like Mexican, Italian, French). I find Vietnamese restaurant food in the U.S. way too sweet/sugary. Northern style restaurants seem very rare here.
I love how your recipes are detailed and contain lots of tips and tricks that other recipe writers leave out. For example, the timing of how long to leave certain ingredients simmering in the pho bo broth is crucial.
I like that your website is a mix of traditional recipes along with some recipes for trending foods in Vietnam. It’s cool to hear about certain foods and drinks I haven’t come across in the US, like the orange juice ginger lemongrass tea drink. I like all those ingredients individually, why didn’t I think to put them together?!
Lastly (back to the pho bo) I’m fascinated that quay is considered essential because my parents never served this with pho bo. They serve it with chao ga though. Another pho bo topping that I saw my grandpa order at restaurants are the poached white ends of scallions (like last 2 in) in a tiny bowl of oily broth. What is that called and do you notice other people ordering this in Hanoi?
Thank you for reading the recipe and sharing your family story with me. Your comment is such a joy to read :). I’m happy to hear that the cha ca la vong turned out great. It is always one of my most favorite traditional dishes of Hanoi.
The poached white part of scallions in a bowl of broth is called “hành chần”. And yes, it’s possible to order a separate bowl like that at traditional pho stalls here but I think it is a little less common to serve it separately like that. These days, all regular pho bowls in Hanoi are already topped with the white parts of scallions shredded in half lengthwise and then the hot broth will be poured over. When I make it at home, I usually bring the broth to a boil, drop the shredded white parts in the broth for several seconds before putting it in the bowl to reduce some of the raw taste. I included the white scallion parts in the list of ingredients, but I will add this note to the recipe to make the instructions clearer.
I’m not exactly sure since when quay was served with pho. Some sources say around the 70s-80s. Both my husband and I were born in the 80s and during our childhood in the 90s, we already ate pho with quay. This is also a Northern thing. I’ve never seen quay at any Southern pho places in Saigon.
When we lived in the US, almost all Vietnamese restaurants we tried were Southern style (I think it’s probably a history related thing). Southern style cooking uses sugar to season food much more often than Northern style. I remember my cousin once took us to a pho place near San Francisco which makes pretty tasty Northern beef pho as well as chicken pho.
I have since moved back to Vietnam and lived in Saigon. Though both my husband and I enjoy the food in Saigon, we still retain our Northern palate like your parents. Your mother, grandmother and great-grandmother were all from Hanoi, so I’m sure they were particular about their Vietnamese food. After all, I think we all crave the flavors we grew up with.
You know, since I moved back to Vietnam, I keep feeling amazed by the food scene here. People come up with new dishes so frequently. I personally enjoy testing and sharing recipes of the newer food trending in Vietnam very much. By the way, if you like kumquat, kumquat lemongrass tea is also very popular now :).
I haven’t tried this yet but I just want to say thank you so much for giving such a traditional recipe that makes sure to explain the difference between Northern and Southern pho. I used to live in an area that had a lot of North Vietnamese people, but I’ve moved to a different part of the country and I think the Vietnamese restaurants are all Southern style. I have been missing and craving northern pho and tried making my own broth a few times but it wasn’t quite right. This recipe answers a lot of the questions I have had and I think will finally help me get the taste I am looking for. I tried one other recipe from this site a few months ago, the mi vit tiem, and it was delicious, so I am excited to try this 🙂 Thank you for sharing the flavors of your culture with us
I still remember you tried the mi vit tiem recipe and left me a comment on that post. Glad to see you’re back to check out another recipe. I hope you will also like this one :).
I had a year living in London several years ago and most Vietnamese restaurants I tried there served Northern style food. It also seems to be the case in some other big cities in Europe. Then I moved to the US and at the beginning, I was very surprised that most Vietnamese restaurants there cooked food in Southern style. It’s not just pho but a lot of other traditional dishes are prepared/seasoned differently in the North and the South.